化妝品和暗瘡 的概念


化妝品與暗瘡 Facial Cosmetics and Acne

What exactly does a patient mean when reporting that a certain cosmetic causes her face to "break out?" This phrase may refer to formation of a comedone, papule, pustule, nodule, cyst, or red rash. In addition, patients often have difficulty establishing a cause-and-effect relationship. From a dermatologic standpoint, the term that is still used to refer to cosmetic-related acne is acne cosmetica.

Acne cosmetica is a concept that was developed many years ago when cosmetics could indeed cause comedone formation. The issue of comedogenicity in relation to cosmetics arose in 1972 when Kligman and Mills described a low-grade acne characterized by closed comedones on the cheeks of women aged 20-25. Many of these women had not experienced adolescent acne. The authors proposed that substances present in cosmetic products induced the formation of closed comedones and, in some cases, a papulopustular eruption. Presently, personal communication with Dr. Kligman indicates that he no longer believes currently marketed cosmetics cause comedone formation, yet acne related to cosmetics remains a problem.

這是源於 1972 年 Dr. Kligman 認為 化妝品的成份,可引致暗瘡。可是這個概念,對現在的化妝品 (指有一定質素的),已不太合用了。

The literature reports lists of ingredients that supposedly cause acne, but finding a formulation that possesses none of these substances is practically impossible. The list contains some of the most effective emollients (eg, octyl stearate, isocetyl stearate), detergents (eg, sodium lauryl sulfate), occlusive moisturizers (eg, mineral oil, petrolatum, sesame oil, cocoa butter), and emulsifiers found in the cosmetic industry. A product line that avoids all of these substances would not perform well on the skin and would possess low cosmetic acceptability.
There are many myths regarding cosmetics and cosmeceuticals and the acne that they may or may not cause. Examining these myths to determine the medical truth is worthwhile.


The first myth is that cosmeceuticals do not produce acne if labeled noncomedogenic and nonacnegenic. Similar to the term hypoallergenic, labels that describe products as noncomedogenic and nonacnegenic are marketing claims carrying no implied regulation. They were developed to create a new consumer image for cosmetic lines designed to minimize acne.

一些標榜 ‘不引致暗瘡’ ‘不引致毛孔阻塞’ 標語 ,跟 ‘低敏配方’一樣,都是沒有標準的市場學字句,只在於建立消費者對產品的信心。看到這些字句,購買時才有信心?

In order to market a product as noncomedogenic, rabbit ear or human comedogenicity testing should be undertaken. Both the animal and the human model are based on the presence of new comedone formation after the exposure of skin to the finished cosmetic. Human testing is considered to be more accurate, but the results are highly dependent on the skill of the contract testing laboratory. Acnegenic claims are based on human use testing and the evaluation of volunteer subjects who report any increased acne following product use. Many manufacturers, however, make noncomedogenic and nonacnegenic claims based on the safety profiles of the individual ingredients in the formulation. This is inaccurate. Noncomedogenic and nonacnegenic claims should be made based on clinical testing of the finished formulation. Therefore, dermatologists should still consider all products labeled noncomedogenic or nonacnegenic as potentially problematic.

(只看着那成份表,用產品中個別成份的功效,作為分析該產品的理據,也是不對的。 要考慮各成份互相作用,互相影響,穩定性和吸收度,光破壞和氧化分解⋯等等。這個跟給你食材表,就以爲可以煮出美餸菜一樣的道理!不是天真了一點嗎? Dr James)

The second myth is that mineral oil is comedogenic. Mineral oil is one of the most common ingredients in skin care products and colored cosmetics. It is a lightweight inexpensive oil that is odorless and tasteless. One of the common concerns regarding the use of mineral oil is its presence on several lists of comedogenic substances. These comedogenic lists were developed many years ago yet remain frequently quoted in the dermatologic literature.
Several points are important to consider. First, different grades of mineral oil are available. Industrial grade mineral oil is used as a machine lubricant and is not of the purity required for skin application. Cosmetic grade mineral oil is the purist form without contaminants. Industrial grade mineral oil may be comedogenic, but cosmetic grade mineral oil is not. Quality manufacturers only purchase quality products from quality suppliers who guarantee the standards of the materials they provide. This author considers cosmetic grade mineral oil noncomedogenic based on findings from testing performed for the skin care industry.

礦物油會引致毛孔阻塞和暗瘡? 礦物油以不同的純度分成多個等級,有工業用,也有最潔淨的和沒有用污染物的。後者是不會引致毛孔阻塞和暗瘡,現在的化妝品,都是用它作成份。

The third myth is that sunscreens produce acne. Many patients note the occurrence of breakouts following the use of sunscreens. These patients typically present with perifollicular papules and pustules in a random distribution over the face. Eruptions appear within 24-48 hours after wearing a facial sunscreen. This author has not performed biopsies on patients who develop sunscreen-related acne, but presented below is a hypothesis based on how sunscreens function.
Most sunscreens available today are based primarily on UVB-absorbing ingredients, such as octylmethoxycinnamate, oxybenzone, and homosalate. Many also have UVA-absorbing ingredients, such as avobenzone, titanium dioxide, or zinc oxide, as secondary sunscreens. All of the UVB sunscreens and avobenzone function by transforming ultraviolet radiation to heat energy through a process known as resonance delocalization. This heat energy is appreciated by many patients who state that they do not like wearing sunscreens because the gels or lotions make them feel hot.
In some patients, the increased sweating induced by the sunscreens and the sunny weather may cause increased activity of the eccrine glands. This may cause miliaria rubra that may be magnified by the occlusive nature of the water-resistant, rub-proof sunscreen product. Thus, much of the problem with sunscreen-induced acne is the formation of papules or pustules around the eccrine duct ostia without the sebaceous gland involvement that characterizes true acne.


Myth Four is that a complex skin care regimen of multiple cleansers, moisturizers, and ancillary skin care products is necessary for clear skin. There are many different approaches to skin care, from the no-nonsense soap-and-water approach to the 20-step skin care routine. No routine is established as better. In Japan, skin care is a complex ritual of multiple cleansers, toners, and moisturizers. The Japanese are also considered to have the most sensitive skin of all races, and the incidence of atopic dermatitis is dramatically rising in Japan. Perhaps this due to the use of extensive skin care products. However, without doubt, the more the skin is manipulated, the more opportunity there is for problems to arise. The best advice may be to recommend moderation in skin care.[22 ]


Myth 5 is that acne breakouts after age 30 years in women are rare and benefit from special skin care. Acne after age 30 years is actually becoming more and more common in women. The cause of this trend is not known, but it appears to be related to fluctuating hormones and the onset of premenopause and perimenopause. This supposition is based on the observation that the acne is not characterized by open and closed comedones, but rather inflammatory papules and pustules. Because these lesions are in the lower epidermis and dermis, special skin care routines cannot have a dramatic effect. Thus, the use of oral antibiotics and hormonal therapies, such as birth control pills or estrogen replacement therapy, are the best options for acne control in this population. Cosmetics and skin care products have little effect on this type of acne. Many mature patients mistake this cyclic hormonal acne for acne related to cosmetic product use.


For all purposes, acne cosmetica is a concept of the past, which the industry has done its best to remedy. Skin care manufacturers are keenly aware of the need to test and formulate products without skin side effects. Yet, many acne myths persist. This article has posed possible answers to some of the most common acne myths submitted by several dermatologists.

化妝品引發的暗瘡 ,是舊概念了。現在的護膚品和化妝品生產商, 利用正確的測試, 致力改善產品質素,令使用者用得放心。

Acknowledgement:  Zoe Diana Draelos, MD, Primary Investigator, Dermatology Consulting Services; Private Practice Updated: Apr 30, 2009

暗瘡粉刺 三 (常見的原因)


青春期,懷孕期,女性週期: 體內激素的轉變,油脂分泌特別旺盛。
生活壓力: 男性激素相對地活躍,引致過多油脂分泌,阻塞毛孔。
皮膚接觸令毛孔阻塞的物質,混合油脂。Acne Cosmetica : 化妝品阻塞毛孔引致或惡化暗瘡。
成熟型皮膚: 角質層更換脫落減慢,毛孔亦易被阻塞。
藥物影響, 某些內分泌或內科病… 等等,還有很多引致皮膚失衡的原因。

只要不讓三種狀況(油脂分泌, 阻塞毛孔及暗瘡細菌增生) 同時出現,把一種或以上的狀況解決,暗瘡便不會形成。

減少皮脂線分泌: 控油的口服或塗抹藥物,維生素a酸衍生物,果酸…等等。
去角質,減少皮脂線阻塞: 果酸或維生素a酸衍生物,皮膚護理。
減少細菌增生: 具殺菌消炎作用的暗瘡藥膏和口服抗生素。
女性激素藥物: 抑制男性激素,減少油脂分泌,阻塞毛孔。
類固醇: 減低發炎。

說是容易,做是難!明白這些誘因是不容易處理的。如青春期激素變化,生理週期,激素失衡,控制生活壓力…「你有壓力,我有壓力」忙碌的香港人嘛! 可是還是要努力地做點工夫。

暗瘡粉刺 一 (序)
暗瘡粉刺 二 (形成暗瘡的元素)
暗瘡粉刺 三 (常見的原因)
暗瘡粉刺 四 (暗瘡處理 一)
暗瘡粉刺 五 (暗瘡處理 二)
暗瘡粉刺 六 (暗瘡處理 三)
暗瘡粉刺 七 (暗瘡處理 四)

fata Morgana 3 2009 by Michael Lam

fata Morgana 3 2009 by Michael Lam

All Rights reserved by Dr James Clinic. Unauthorized duplication is prohibited.